Movies to Watch After Totally Killer | Similar Films Like Totally Killer
Blumhouse’s latest time travel slasher comedy Totally Killer dropped on Amazon Prime Video on October 6, 2023. Directed by Nahnatchka Khan, the film features Kiernan Shipka, Olivia Holt, Charlie Gillespie, and Troy L. Johnson in the leading roles.
The film is about Jamie Hughes who travels back to 1987 after her mother is killed by the Sweet 16 Killer, who returns 35 years after the first murder spree. She teams up with her mom in order to stop the killer, saving her mother, and other victims. Jamie must catch the killer and return to her timeline before she is trapped in the past forever.
Totally Killer is fun to watch for sure. It is a blend of slasher and comedy which makes it one of the best movies of this year. Moreover, the film has received mixed reviews but overall it was worth watching. In case anyone has skipped it then give it a try. Check out the list of movies to watch after Totally Killer.
Movies to Watch After Totally Killer

Happy Death Day
Christopher Landon’s Happy Death Day is an enjoyable film that met with positive reviews from fans upon release in 2017. The film is about a college student Theresa “Tree” Gelbman who is murdered on her birthday night and finds herself reliving the same day over and over until she discovers her murderer.
It was not a typical horror film that frightened you, but it gave you chill and pure delight with elements of comedy, horror, and romance. Jessica Rothe’s captivating performance won the hearts of many as she nailed the character, adding humor that engaged the audience.
Directed by Christopher Landon and written by Scott Lobdell, ‘Happy Death Day’ was produced by Jason Blum through his Blumhouse Productions banner. The film was released on October 13, 2017, and grossed $125 million worldwide on a $4.8 million budget.
Where to Watch Happy Death Day – The film is available for rent or buy on Vudu Fandango, Amazon Prime Video, and Apple+ TV.
The Final Girls
The Final Girls has an interesting plot that hooks the audience to the screen. The plot of The Final Girls and Totally Killer share plenty of similarities, including time travel, a masked murderer, and a mother-daughter bond.
The film is about a girl named Max Cartwright who lost her mother Amanda Cartwright in a car accident three years ago. Amanda was a horror movie actress who became famous because of her character Nancy in the cult slasher film Camp Bloodbath 1 & 2. Max is invited by her friend to share some words after the screening of her mother’s films. Something strange happens in the theatre and Max along with her friends trapped in the movie. Now, they have to face the serial killer and save their and Max’s mom’s life.
Todd Strauss-Schulson directed the film while the script was penned by M.A. Fortin and Joshua John Miller. The film is jointly produced by Michael London and Janice Williams under the banners of Groundswell Productions, Studio Solutions, and Ulterior Productions.
Where to Watch The Final Girls – The film is available for rent or buy on Vudu Fandango, Amazon Prime Video, Google Play, and Apple+ TV.
The Babysitter Film Series
Netflix’s slasher comedy two-part film series The Babysitter and The Babysitter: Killer Queen could be the best option after Totally Killer.
The Babysitter (2017) – Directed by McG and written by Brian Duffield, The Babysitter received positive reviews from the critics. It is about a boy Cole Johnson who finds her babysitter is part of a satanic cult that wants to kill him.
The Babysitter: Killer Queen (2020) – Sequel of The Babysitter, It was also directed by McG who co-wrote the screenplay along with Dan Lagana, Brad Morris, and Jimmy Warden. Two years after the events of the first film, Cole Johnson must again fight to ensure his survival after a secret is unburied, as he is hunted by demonic enemies, both old and new.

Where to Watch The Babysitter – The film is available for streaming on Netflix but a subscription is required.
Fear Street Franchise
The Fear Street Trilogy is an American slasher horror film directed by Leigh Janiak. It follows the story of a couple of teenagers who work to break the curse that has been over their town for hundreds of years. The films are based on the horror fiction book of the same name published by R. L. Stine.
All three films received overall positive reviews from critics and fans all enjoyed. Fans have been expecting the arrival of the fourth part of the film but Netflix hasn’t confirmed anything about it. However, the director hinted at the possibility of future projects on Fear Street.

The film trilogy was shot back to back and released on Netflix on a weekly basis.
Where to Watch The Fear Street Trilogy – The trilogy is available for streaming on Netflix.
Scream (2022)
The Scream franchise is also considered to be the best slasher film series ever but Matt Bettinelli-Olpin & Tyler Gillett’s directorial venture Scream which was released in 2022 has received widespread appreciation.
The official synopsis reads “Twenty-five years after a streak of brutal murders shocked the quiet town of Woodsboro, a new killer has donned the Ghostface mask and begins targeting a group of teenagers to resurrect secrets from the town’s deadly past.”
Where to Watch Scream 2022 – Scream film is streaming on Netflix, Paramount+, and Showtime with subscription, and is available for rent on Vudu Fandango, Prime Video, and Apple TV.
Freaky
Blumhouse’s comedy slasher Freaky is an entertaining film that you shouldn’t miss. Its humor with slasher scenes makes the film the best in this category. Besides, the star cast performance was praised, with the direction and screenplay.
Get ready for a funny and scary movie! Freaky, which is about a teenage girl named Millie. Something weird happens in the town. An infamous killer stabs her with a special dagger, and they switch bodies in the very next morning. Now, the scared girl only has one day to switch her body before she’s stuck looking like a middle-aged serial killer forever. Can she do it? Watch the exciting movie to find out!
Freaky is not a serious or gory slasher film. If that’s what you’re looking for in a movie, then you should skip this one.
Where to Watch Freaky 2020 Movie – The film is available for rent or buy on Vudu Fandango, Amazon Prime Video, and Apple+ TV.